We are pleased to present this monumental work by Nuzhat J. Haneef.

The HTML is being formatted and some of the work has been done. You can preview it by following the links on the left hand side of this page. Meanwhile, you can download the PDF version. The size of the file is 8 megabytes and will take some time to download. An Urdu translation will be provided in due course.

(Ahmedi.org management)
Download

One of the problems with being an "informed Ahmadi", i.e. one who has read MGA, is the challenge to be logical just as we are logical and open in the rest of our lives.

Nuzhat J. Haneef has bridged this gap and has trusted her reason with a painstaking labour of love -- and has fulfilled her obligation to God by reflecting and pondering to the best of her ability. May Allah reward her efforts and lead her to the goal of her search for the truth.

Haneef's work hits hard on two points:

• It is impossible to logicaly defend Mirza Ghulam Ahmad on each and every statement that he wrote, and some rationalization is required.
  
• It is impossible to logically believe in ALL the claims of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, as required by the Qadianis' initiation formula.